What Christmas is All About. #1, What Christmas Is Not All About!

Wow, it’s been fifty years.  Sure doesn’t seem like it.  December 9^th will be the 50^th anniversary of the first showing of Charlie Brown Christmas.  And while most of us grew up watching the animated special there were a number of hesitations about the show when it was aired.  As a matter of fact, for the sponsor and the network all they were kind of hoping was that it wouldn’t be a complete disaster, and they would be able to shelve it and hopefully people would forget all about it. 

And maybe you are wondering what the problem was.  It wasn’t a problem; it was a multitude of problems.  When Coca Cola and CBS first started the project they were visualizing a little light hearted animated Christmas special with laugh tracks and secular themes.  Instead they ended up with this melancholy tale complete with jazz music, what kid listens to jazz? And a reading from the King James Version of the Bible.   

Peanuts creator Charles Shultz insisted that no laugh track be used, in the meeting Shultz said “The network should let the people at home enjoy the show at their own speed, in their own way” and then he walked out of the room ending the argument. Sounds like Schulz had a little bit of Lucy in him that day.  

Shultz also refused to use adult actors for the voices and instead he cast neighbourhood children for the parts to preserve the innocence but also to make it a little funnier and edgier.  One snag was that some of the kids were so young they couldn’t read and had to be fed their parts line by line.  The only adult voice used was for Snoopy.   

But in spite of their worst fears Charlie Brown Christmas has become an enduring part of  the Christmas Season. How many folks here have watched the Charlie Brown Christmas at some point in their life?   

And the entire show comes down to the question asked by Charlie Brown “Isn’t there anyone who knows what Christmas is all about?” 

And over the next few weeks we will be looking at: What Christmas is all About, but today we are going to look at some of the answers given in the movie, because that was what was frustrating to Charlie Brown, what he was hearing from the others. 

And even fifty years later I think we can find a snapshot of society in the cast of Charlie Brown’s Christmas. 

For Snoopy Christmas is all about Christmas  It doesn’t take long for us to discover that Snoopy is a big Christmas fan, he seems to love Christmas, but what he really loves is the idea of Christmas. 

He loves all the hoopla and the excitement, the lights and the glitz.  Snoopy would be right at the curb for the parade of lights, and be first in line to see the Christmas tree lit in Grand Parade.  And we all know people like Snoopy.   

My sister decorates for Christmas at Halloween, and then she dresses up as Mrs. Santa Claus and hands out candy canes to the trick or treaters while Christmas music plays in the background. 

There is a lady who works at Tim Hortons who is obsessed with Christmas, I’m sure if you went in on March 17 and asked her she could tell you how many days it is until Christmas, and she talks about trees and lights, gifts and meals but that’s where it ends.  I’ve invited her out to our Christmas services and she’s not interested, I think they would interfere with the celebrations. 

For her Christmas is all about the holiday and family and food.  And those aren’t bad things, but they aren’t what Christmas is all about.   

For too many folks a Holy Day has simply become a holiday, and we have lots of holidays to pick from.   

You can have a day off on Thanksgiving, or Labour Day or Canada Day.  And along with the holiday comes the opportunity to spend the time with family and with family comes food.  It’s like church: There’s no meeting without eating. 

But you can have burgers on Canada Day and Ham on Easter and if you are a big turkey fan, that’s what Thanksgiving is for, you really don’t need Christmas.

And it’s easy to get caught up in all the hype of Christmas without understanding what Christmas is all about.   

Jesus came to give you eternal life, not a holiday. 

In contrast to Snoopy we see Lucy and For Lucy Christmas is all about the Effort.    Lucy is so wrapped up in making sure that everything is just right for Christmas she misses Christmas.  She’s organizing the Christmas play, is responsible for finding the perfect tree and even needs to find time to help Charlie Brown get into the Christmas spirit.   

When Charlie Brown confesses to Lucy during their counselling session that he doesn’t understand Christmas and it leaves him feeling down instead of happy her solution is easy.  She says, “You need involvement, you need to get involved in some real Christmas projects.”  And then she recruits him to direct the Christmas play, because for her that’s what makes Christmas, Christmas.  All the stuff you do. 

There’s gifts and cards to be bought.  Food to be cooked, presents to be wrapped, letters to be written and cards to be mailed.  There are the staff parties to attend, turkeys to be stuffed and church appearances to be made.   

And it’s not just that she’s busy, Snoopy is busy but he’s happy busy.  The season lights a fire in Snoopy he’s laughing and dancing, not one bit of stress will you find in our canine friend.   

But the hustle and bustle of the season just makes Lucy grumpier and more cynical.  She is stressed and resents what she has to do and ultimately she tells Charlie Brown  “ Look, Charlie, let’s face it. We all know that Christmas is a big commercial racket. It’s run by a big eastern syndicate, you know.” 

Sociologist Robert Lynd nailed the difference between Snoopy and Lucy with this statement “There are some people who want to throw their arms round you simply because it is Christmas; there are other people who want to strangle you simply because it is Christmas.”  It doesn’t take long to figure out who’s who here. 

There are lots of people who are like Lucy and Christmas means lists and obligations and lots of stress and regrets.  And there is enough stress and regrets in life without adding Christmas to the pile.  So Christmas isn’t about the stuff we do.

Jesus came to give you eternal life, not just more things to do.

And then there is Sally, Sally is Charlie Browns’ baby sister.  The little girl who read Sally’s lines was so young that she didn’t know how to read and she had to be fed the lines, bit by bit and then she would repeat them back.  And For Sally Christmas is all about Sally  

She wants Charlie Brown to help her write her letter to Santa and when he tells her he’s busy she just brushes it off and forces the paper and pencil on him.   

Her one concession to what others are feeling is summed up when she finishes her letter to Santa by dictating “If it seems to complicated, make it easy on yourself and just send money.  How about tens and twenties?”   

For some folks all of Christmas revolves around what’s in it for them.  And it’s all about making them happy?  Will the date work for them?  Will the food work for them? Will the gift be what they were expecting and hoping for? They even insist on picking the Christmas special that everyone will watch.    

Sally sums it up when she tells her brother “All I want is what I have coming to me.  All I want is my fair share.” 

And we might expect that of a four-year-old, but not adults.  But for many that is the reality.  Regardless of our pious denials most of us will be looking forward to what’s under the tree, with our name on it. 

Probably, if we were willing to be totally honest we could say with C.S. Lewis “I never had a selfless thought since I was born.”

But here is the reality, Christmas isn’t about the stuff we do and it’s certainly not about the stuff we get. 

Jesus came to give you eternal life, not Christmas presents. 

Let’s not forget the hero of our story, because for Charlie Brown Christmas is all about Despair And Charlie Brown isn’t alone.  

For the past few years we’ve had a Blue Christmas service, on December 21^st, this year we are simply calling it “Silent Night”  but the tag line remains the same. “Christmas isn’t Merry for everyone.” 

Shane Kelly. Manager of the Irish Association for Counselling and Psychotherapy says “Christmas is a time of happiness, reunions, family time, and these celebrations can heighten feelings of loneliness and despair.”

At the beginning of the story Charlie Brown tells Linus “I think there’s something wrong with me Linus, Christmas is coming, but I’m not happy.  I don’t feel the way I’m suppose to feel.  I just don’t understand Christmas, I guess. I like getting presents and sending Christmas cards and decorating trees and all that, but I’m still not happy.  I always end up feeling depressed.”     

Christmas seemed to magnify and polarize what Charlie Brown felt his life was like the rest of the year, in one scene he goes out and looks in his empty mail box for the Christmas Cards that aren’t there and he says.  “I know nobody likes me why do we need a holiday season to emphasize it?” 

For some it might be a reminder of someone who is no longer there, either through death, divorce or simply distance.  But when everyone else is celebrating family their loss becomes more pronounced.   

Or maybe it’s because we can’t afford the expectations that are placed upon us by society. 

In his 1973 song “If We Make it Through December” Merle Haggert Sang.

“Got laid off down at the factory 
And their timing’s not the greatest in the world;
Heaven knows I been working hard,
Wanted Christmas to be right for daddy’s girl;
I don’t mean to hate December,
It’s meant to be the happy time of year;
And my little girl don’t understand
Why daddy can’t afford no Christmas here” 

And nobody else in the story understands, to them Charlie Brown is just being Charlie Brown. 

And simply saying “cheer up”, or “get involved” or reminding them how others are worse off than they are doesn’t help. 

If you find yourself in that camp, I would like to invite you out to our Silent Night Service on December 21^st, we won’t try to force you to cheer up, it is simply a time of reflection in a service that is a little quieter than most of our Christmas offerings.  

Jesus came to give you eternal life, not despair. 

For Linus Christmas is all about Christmas And maybe you are thinking, “Denn must be losing it, that’s what he said about Snoopy.” But Snoopy and Linus are at opposite ends of the Christmas spectrum.   

Snoopy is all about the secular aspects of Christmas while Linus seems to be all about the spiritual side of it.   

Linus seems to be the one who gets it, he recites the Christmas story from memory, from the King James version no less, and he challenges people to look deeper into the Christmas story.  

After he recites the Christmas story he proudly turns to Charlie Brown and proclaims: “And that’s what Christmas is all about Charlie Brown.”   

And we all know people like, Linus they are the ones the “Keep Christ in Christmas”  button on their winter coat, the “Jesus is the reason for the season” bumper sticker on their cars and the inflatable nativity scene on their front lawn.  Not that there is anything wrong with an inflatable nativity scene.   

They are the first to challenge the commercialization of Christmas and sometimes they go to the extreme of demanding that we fire Santa and shoot all the reindeer, pull down the lights and return the presents.   

The problem is that on January 1^st they pack up Christmas, along with their nativity scene and put it away for another year.  Sure, they keep Christ in Christmas but that’s where he stays, in Christmas.   Just as some people are guilty of leaving Christ on the Cross after the Easter story Linus is content to leave the baby Jesus sleeping quietly in the manger after Christmas is over.

Linus wants to keep Christ in Christmas the same way he wants to keep the Great Pumpkin in Halloween.  That’s where he belongs. 

But how much difference has the Christmas story made in the life of Linus?  In the opening scene when Charlie Brown is deep in despair Linus encourages him by saying “Out of all the Charlie Browns in the world, you’re the Charlie Browniest.”  Linus where’s the love?

Jesus came to give you eternal life, not a religious celebration.

And maybe at this point you are thinking, “Wow If Christmas isn’t even about Christmas what is it about?”   

Well, over the next few weeks we are going to travel back in time 2000 years to see if we can find the answers. 

But here are some things to keep in mind as we look ahead.

Christmas Isn’t Just a Day or an Event.  As long as we see Christmas as December 25^th or even view it in a broader sense as “The Christmas Season” we will miss what Christmas is all about. 

American President Calvin Coolidge said  “Christmas is not a time or a season but a state of mind. To cherish peace and good will, to be plenteous in mercy, is to have the real spirit of Christmas.”  You see Christmas has to be as valid and valuable in July as it is in December. 

If Christmas doesn’t make a difference in how we live every day, not just December 25^th than it has made a difference at all.  Because when we celebrate the birth of Christ we should be celebrating something bigger than a baby being born in a barn 2000 years ago.  With the birth of Jesus, we need to be celebrating changed lives, a changed world and changed eternities. 

Otherwise we are like the shepherds who were invited to celebrate the birth of the Messiah, they showed up they rejoiced and they disappeared.  Not a mention again of the shepherds, Jesus birth had a great immediate impact on them, but nothing long lasting and certainly nothing eternal.

Christmas has to last longer than the leftovers if we are to truly understand what Christmas is all about.  Charles Dickens wrote “I will honour Christmas in my heart, and try to keep it all the year.”

Because Dickens understood the truth that if Christmas doesn’t change your life, then you’ve missed what Christmas is all about

And Christmas Isn’t About a Baby Being Born  Too many people who proudly talk about keeping Christ in Christmas or reminding people that Jesus is the reason for the season have a one dimensional view of Jesus and it is summed up in Luke 2:7 ^KJV And she brought forth her firstborn son, and wrapped him in swaddling clothes, and laid him in a manger; because there was no room for them in the inn.

And truthfully that’s how it all began, Paul reminds us of that in Galatians 4:4  But when the right time came, God sent his Son, born of a woman, subject to the law.  I love that passage, because it reminds us that Jesus wasn’t born at just any time he was born at the right time.  But let’s never forget that the baby born in the manger wasn’t just the son of Mary, he was the Son of God. 

Too often in our haste to make sure that at Christmas people take the time to celebrate Christ’s birth we miss the enormity of Christ’s birth.

Ken Herr in the Wesleyan Bible Commentary reminds us “This was not just another baby or another birthday. God was born in human likeness—the Divine taking upon himself the limitations of humanity.” 

Which is why Paul reminded the early Christians in Philippians 2:6-7  Though he (Jesus) was God, he did not think of equality with God as something to cling to.  Instead, he gave up his divine privileges; he took the humble position of a slave and was born as a human being.

Did you catch that?  Jesus was God! God!  He created the universe, he shaped the planets in his hand and cast the milky way into the night sky, he always was and always will be and he chose to come to earth as a new born child.

God chose to take part in the full range of the human experience, beginning with the trauma of his birth, and I can’t imagine much more traumatic in this life than the birth experience for the new born.  Everybody coos and talks about how beautiful of an experience birth is, if a new born could talk I’m not sure they would agree that what they had just gone through was beautiful.

And for the next thirty-three years Jesus lived his life just as we live our lives, from potty training to puberty, Jesus experienced life just like us. 

When your teenager says in the midst of their angst.  “You just don’t understand” they somehow think you were magically conceived as an adult and never went through what they are going through. 

In the same way we sometimes yell at God, “You just don’t understand.”  But we are reminded in  Hebrews 2:18  Since he (Jesus)  himself has gone through suffering and testing, he is able to help us when we are being tested.  I would suspect that Jesus fell and skinned his knees, that he had the cold and measles, that he was probably teased at some point by other kids.

He may have had his heart broken by the little girl with red hair and peered into an empty mailbox waiting for the card that would never appear.  

What is Christmas about?  Sure it began with a child being born of a virgin, far from home.  And there were angels and shepherds and wise men with gifts.  But that was just the beginning.  And for some it seems to have ended thirty-three years and six miles down the road when Jesus was crucified, but that too was just a beginning.   

Who will define Christmas this year for you?  You will.